Classic and Contemporary Poetry: Explained

David Wagoner’s “Fisherman’s Wife” is an enigmatic and deeply lyrical exploration of the intersection between human relationships, nature, and the mysterious instincts that bind the two. Through its haunting imagery and understated narrative, the poem delves into themes of autonomy, sacrifice, and the unspoken connections that exist between individuals and the natural world.

The poem begins with an act of release: “When she said, ‘No,’ I freed the hook.” The speaker’s immediate obedience to the wife’s refusal sets a tone of deference and respect. The act of releasing the trout becomes a symbolic gesture, reflecting a broader dynamic between the couple and the natural world they inhabit. The trout, described as a “two-foot rainbow,” is more than just a fish—it is a vivid, living embodiment of the beauty and vitality of the natural world. The speaker’s repeated attempts to “scoop it, belly down, below the surface” highlight his concern for the fish’s well-being, as well as his hope for its survival. Yet, despite his efforts, the fish’s movement—“tilted... its tailfin stiff”—suggests the tenuousness of life and the limits of human intervention.

The wife’s second “No” marks a pivotal moment in the poem. Her response is resolute yet understated, and what follows is an extraordinary act that blurs the line between the human and the natural. “She had stepped casually in her summer dress / Into the lake and under, catching the trout.” This surreal image of the wife entering the water and cradling the fish in her arms is charged with symbolism. Her action transcends mere practicality; it is almost mythical in its grace and intimacy. By stepping into the lake, she becomes part of the environment, aligning herself with the fish in a way that the speaker’s earlier actions could not achieve.

The description of the wife “breathing less than it, not shutting her eyes” conveys a sense of communion with the trout and the water. Her calm demeanor—“her face / As calm as that water deep below the cedars”—suggests a profound connection to the natural world, one that goes beyond mere interaction to a state of being. This moment, where the wife submerges herself, holding the trout, reflects a kind of sacrifice or transformation, as though she temporarily surrenders her human identity to align herself with the fish and its watery domain.

The speaker’s act of pulling her back to the surface—“I caught her by the hair, bringing her back / Alive”—is charged with tension. While it saves her from potential harm, it also disrupts the delicate equilibrium she had established with the trout and the water. The fish’s escape—“its red-and-silver side / Flashing beyond her, down into the dark”—marks the culmination of the encounter. The trout, now free, symbolizes the elusiveness of life and the limits of human control. Its tail’s final flick and its disappearance into the depths suggest both liberation and loss.

The poem’s closing lines are steeped in quiet reflection: “We sat on edge till the moon came out, but nothing / Rose, belly up, to mock it at our feet.” This serene image of the couple sitting by the water, waiting under the moonlight, captures a shared moment of stillness and contemplation. The absence of a floating, dead fish “to mock” their efforts underscores the ambiguous resolution of the scene. The trout has returned to its natural element, and the couple, having witnessed its release, is left to grapple with the significance of their actions and the unspoken emotions that linger between them.

Wagoner’s use of restrained language and vivid imagery enhances the poem’s emotional depth. The lake, with its “dark” depths and “cedars” along its shore, serves as a powerful setting that reflects the complexity and mystery of the human experience. The interplay between light and dark, from the trout’s “red-and-silver side” to the “moon” and its reflection, mirrors the tension between presence and absence, life and death, action and inaction.

In “Fisherman’s Wife,” the titular character emerges as a figure of strength, intuition, and connection to the natural world. Her actions are not explained or justified; they simply are, challenging the speaker—and the reader—to accept the enigmatic beauty of her choices. The poem, in turn, becomes a meditation on the boundaries of understanding, the power of instinct, and the shared, fleeting moments that define relationships.

In conclusion, “Fisherman’s Wife” is a masterful exploration of the relationship between humans and nature, as well as the dynamics of love and autonomy. Through its rich imagery and quiet tension, the poem invites readers to reflect on the mysteries of connection—whether between two people or between humanity and the natural world. It is a poignant reminder of the beauty and fragility of life, as well as the profound truths that often lie just beyond our grasp.

Copyright (c) 2025 PoetryExplorer

Discover our Poem Explanations and Poet Analyses!

Other Poems of Interest...